JK Rowling faces new controversy after Jon Stewart criticizes his anti-Semitic tropes in Harry Potter

Jon Stewart has criticized the already besieged JK Rowling for the goblins who run the Gringotts Bank in his Harry Potter film series, calling them an obvious anti-Semitic trope.

The former host of The Daily Show raised the question on the Dec. 16 episode of his podcast, The Problem with Jon Stewart.

Stewart, who is Jewish, wondered why Rowling chose to “throw Jews in there to run the fucking underground bank” in a fictional world where people “can ride dragons and have pet owls.”

The Harry Potter author is no stranger to controversy and has been canceled for his comments regarding transgender issues.

Jon Stewart (pictured), who is Jewish, wondered why Rowling chose to ‘throw Jews in there to run the fucking underground bank’ in a fictional world where people ‘can ride dragons and have owls of company “

Stewart called Goblins an obvious anti-Semitic trope and asked why more people hadn't followed suit.  Pictured is a film from the first Harry Potter film

Stewart called Goblins an obvious anti-Semitic trope and asked why more people hadn’t followed suit. Pictured is a film from the first Harry Potter film

Stewart, 59, said the banker goblin characters are based on caricatures of Jews from The Protocols of the Elders of Zion, an infamous anti-Semitic text that claims to show a Jewish plan for world domination.

“This is how you know the Jews are always where they are,” Stewart said in the episode before lamenting the reluctance of those he spoke to to recognize the resemblance.

“I just want to show you a cartoon. And they’re like, “Oh, look at this, this is from Harry Potter!” And you’re like, “No, it’s a caricature of a Jew from an anti-Semitic book.” JK Rowling thought, ‘Can we get these guys to run our bank?’ ‘

Harry Potter author JK Rowling (pictured) is no stranger to the controversy and has been called off for comments regarding transgender issues

Harry Potter author JK Rowling (pictured) is no stranger to the controversy and has been called off for comments regarding transgender issues

An illustration of The Protocols of the Elders Zion

An original illustration by JK Rowling, sketched before Warner Brothers started making the movies

In the photo on the right is an illustration from The Protocols of the Elders of Zion, an anti-Semitic text that claims to show a Jewish plan for world domination. Pictured at left is a sketch of JK Rowling from Harry Potter visiting Gringotts Bank in Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone, long before Warner Brothers took on the film franchise

When he first saw the Harry Potter films, Stewart said he expected other customers in the theater to “be like” shit, she didn’t, in a Wizarding World, to just throw Jews in there to run the fucking underground bank. “And everyone was like” wizards. “

Stewart isn’t the first to call out the goblins – in 2020, Saturday Night Live comedian Pete Davidson expressed similar frustrations.

In the Harry Potter books and films, he said, “the woods are controlled by centaurs, the schools are run by wizards and ghosts, but who controls the banks … Jews of course – of little Jewish goblins with a giant nose “.

Twitter polled the goblin characters before they were even mentioned by the comedians.

A user from December 2019, for example, asks “Why did you give goblin money with a hook nose, Joanne?” “

Another joked: “If you like grateful slaves and hook-nosed banking goblins, you’ll love Harry Potter and the genre’s biological essentialism.”

Rowling, 56, has previously been charged with transphobia after mocking an article online in June 2020 that used the words “menstruating people” instead of “women.”

The possibility that the goblins who run the Gringotts Bank in the Harry Potter universe are crude Jewish stereotypes was raised long before Jon Stewart mentioned the issue in his podcast.

The possibility that the goblins who run the Gringotts Bank in the Harry Potter universe are crude Jewish stereotypes was raised long before Jon Stewart mentioned the issue in his podcast.

Twitter polled the goblin characters before they were even mentioned by the comedians

Twitter polled the goblin characters before they were even mentioned by the comedians

A user from December 2019, for example, asks

A user from December 2019, for example, asks “Why did you give goblin money with a hook nose, Joanne?” “

Another joked:

Another joked: “If you like grateful slaves and hook-nosed banking goblins, you’ll love Harry Potter and the genre’s biological essentialism.”

She then defended herself against the allegations in a heated essay, but has been criticized by some since.

Last week, she hit back at a claim on a U.S. website that she believed there were only two genders.

Rowling wrote: “Small but important point: I never said there were only two genres. There are countless gender identities.

“The question at the heart of this debate is whether sex or gender identity should form the basis for decisions on safeguarding, service provision, sports categories and other areas in which women and girls currently have legal rights and protections.

Rowling, 56, was previously charged with transphobia after mocking an article online in June 2020 that used the words

Rowling, 56, has previously been charged with transphobia after mocking an article online in June 2020 that used the words ‘menstruating people’ instead of ‘women’

In 2020, JK Rowling shared a number of articles regarding biological essentialism and the de-transition of transgender people.

In 2020, JK Rowling shared a number of articles regarding biological essentialism and the de-transition of transgender people.

“The use of the words ‘sex’ and ‘gender’ indifferently masks the central question of this debate.

“If you’re interested in what I actually said, see this – (where I literally say ‘trans lives matter’ and ‘trans rights are human rights.’).

Over the past few weeks, a debate has erupted over whether or not Rowling will appear in Harry Potter’s upcoming reunion on Sky.

It was revealed that in clips from the New Years’ special, the stars praised “the power of her writing” and that she would appear in archive footage.

She is also seen in a 2019 segment discussing the difficult struggle to find an actor to play Harry during the casting of the first film, The Philosopher’s Stone.

The highly anticipated reunion sees Daniel joining fellow leaders Emma Watson, who played Hermione Granger, and Rupert Grint, who played Ron Weasley, along with a host of co-stars marking 20 years since the franchise first aired. .

Despite the star-studded participation, the author of the hit stratospheric franchise was not present at the special reunion – sparking outrage from some fans who accused the creators of trying to erase him because of his opinions.


Source link

Comments are closed.